How Valentino's AI campaign sparked luxury fashion's transparency debate
The Italian house faced fierce criticism in December 2025 after posting AI-generated video for its DeVain bag, raising questions about disclosure limits and consumer trust.

KEY TAKEAWAYS Summary by the editors
- Valentino posted an AI-generated video on Instagram on 2 December 2025 promoting its DeVain handbag and labelled it as AI, but hundreds of comments called it cheap and lazy.
- Research published in the Journal of Advertising Research in 2025 found that when luxury brands disclose AI use, consumers view ads as requiring less effort and perceive the brand as less authentic.
- Getty Images said consumers hold luxury brands to a higher standard than other brands, and full transparency about AI use was not enough to win them over.
- New disclosure laws took effect in 2026, including the EU AI Act on 2 August and New York's synthetic performer law on 9 June.
What happened when Valentino launched its AI campaign in December 2025?
On 2 December 2025, Italian fashion house Valentino faced widespread criticism after posting an AI-generated video on Instagram promoting its Valentino Garavani DeVain handbag. The video, part of what Valentino described as a digital creative project developed with digital artists, featured surreal visuals of bodies and logos morphing around the bag. Nine artists, including Enter The Void, Paul Octavious, Albert Planella, Animus Pax and Total Emotional Awareness, were credited with using AI to assist the project.
Hundreds of comments were posted under the video on Monday, many of them critical of both the visuals and the use of AI. Social media users described the campaign visuals and use of AI as disturbing, sloppy and sad. One user wrote that it was disappointing from a couture fashion house and that advertising campaigns are an opportunity to put talented creatives centre stage, adding that AI in this instance is lazy at best. The backlash only intensified after the brand posted a second AI ad.
Why did transparency not prevent consumer backlash?
The company clearly disclosed that the visuals were AI-generated, which many experts consider a best practice, yet Valentino's insistence on labelling the work as AI-generated did little to soften the blow. Dr Rebecca Swift, senior vice president of creative at Getty Images, said that consumers predominantly view AI-created works as less valuable than human-made images, and that while people are excited by AI-generated content for personal use, they hold brands to a higher standard, especially expensive brands, adding that even full transparency about AI use was not enough to win them over.
Anne-Liese Prem, who leads cultural insights and trends at the creative digital agency Loop, observed that Valentino's candid approach to revealing its use of generative AI showed the right instinct, yet the subsequent public outcry highlighted a deeper cultural tension concerning such technology. Prem told media outlets that without a strong emotional idea behind it, generative AI can make luxury feel less human at a moment when people want human presence more than ever.
What does academic research say about AI disclosure and luxury brands?
A study published in the Journal of Advertising Research in 2025 titled When AI Doesn't Sell Prada examined how consumers react to luxury brand advertisements that disclose the use of AI-generated imagery, finding through three experiments that AI disclosures lead to more negative consumer responses when associated with luxury brands, largely due to perceptions that AI-generated ads require less creative effort, which undermines the perceived authenticity central to luxury branding. However, the negative effects of AI disclosure can be mitigated if the AI-generated imagery is highly creative, which restores a sense of effort and authenticity.
The study, also published in the Journal of Advertising Research, found that consumers respond more negatively when luxury brands feature and disclose AI-generated imagery in their ads, and DoubleVerify's 2026 Media Quality in the Age of AI study found that 43 per cent of consumers in North America said a brand's use of low-quality or uncanny AI-created ads would negatively affect their opinion of the brand. Kantar's Media Reactions 2025 report revealed that only 38 per cent of consumers are excited about the use of AI in advertising, while 47 per cent simply do not trust the technology.
How have other luxury brands approached AI in campaigns?
The backlash reflects a broader challenge luxury brands are navigating as generative AI tools become more widely available, and while AI has been quietly adopted behind the scenes across design, production and operations, its use in front-facing creative remains contentious, particularly in a category built on craftsmanship and human authorship. Other brands experimented with AI in 2025, including Jil Sander, which used AI-assisted campaign imagery in February 2025 and incorporated AI-generated visuals into a broader conceptual campaign.
Berlin-based studio Parallel Pictures, founded in 2021 by Jill Asemota, has produced AI-generated imagery for brands including MCM Worldwide and the German fashion retail group Peek & Cloppenburg, and Asemota said most luxury clients are using AI to extend existing shoots rather than lead with fully AI-native campaigns. Hugo Boss said it has been using AI imagery across e-commerce platforms since 2023, and Peek and Cloppenburg have also tested it on their sites.
What disclosure rules came into force in 2026?
On 2 August 2026, the EU Artificial Intelligence Act took effect, with Article 50 requiring deployers of AI systems that generate deepfakes to disclose that the content is AI-generated or manipulated. The EU rules apply even without intent to deceive, including content that looks or sounds like a real person, which must be labelled even if no deception was intended and even if no real individual is depicted, and disclosure must reach the viewer clearly and at first exposure and cannot be buried in terms and conditions or left to machine-readable metadata alone.
On 11 December 2025, Governor Kathy Hochul signed New York's AI disclosure bill into law, which takes effect on 9 June 2026. New York's Synthetic Performer Disclosure Law, which took effect in June 2026, requires conspicuous disclosure when an ad features an AI-generated synthetic performer. California's SB 1050, signed on 16 September 2026, requires disclosure from 1 January 2027.
What lessons can fashion executives draw from the Valentino case?
The Valentino controversy offers several operational insights for brands. Best practices for using AI in luxury marketing include being transparent about AI usage, centring human creativity, aligning with brand identity and using data-driven insights to guide execution, and brands that treat AI as a creative tool rather than a cost-saving shortcut are more likely to resonate with luxury audiences. When asked what must be true if they are to adopt and trust agents, luxury shoppers in a McKinsey study emphasised transparency about the agent's role (54 per cent), data privacy safeguards (52 per cent) and proven reliability (52 per cent).
The Journal of Advertising Research study concluded that while AI can offer cost-effective visual production, luxury brands should use it judiciously and strategically, particularly ensuring transparency and emphasising creativity to avoid damaging brand perception. Other brands that have faced public criticism after using generative AI models or imagery in their campaigns include Diesel, Gucci, Collina Strada, Baggu, Selkie, Mango, H&M, Zalando, Guess and Levi's.
- Label AI-generated content clearly and prominently, particularly when it features realistic human figures or deepfakes.
- Ensure AI-generated creative work demonstrates high creativity and effort to maintain perceived authenticity.
- Use AI for campaign extensions or operational tasks rather than fully AI-led hero campaigns for luxury positioning.
- Audit all active campaigns for AI content to ensure compliance with EU and US state disclosure laws effective in 2026.
- Monitor consumer sentiment closely, as transparency alone may not prevent backlash if the work is perceived as low-effort.
Frequently asked questions
Did Valentino disclose that its DeVain campaign used AI?
Yes, Valentino clearly labelled the video as AI-generated when it was posted on Instagram on 2 December 2025. Despite this transparency, the campaign still attracted hundreds of critical comments from social media users who described the visuals as cheap, lazy and disturbing.
What does research say about disclosing AI use in luxury advertising?
A 2025 study published in the Journal of Advertising Research found that when luxury brands disclose AI-generated imagery in advertisements, consumers respond more negatively because they perceive the ads as requiring less creative effort, which undermines the brand's perceived authenticity. However, highly creative AI-generated imagery can mitigate this negative effect.
What AI disclosure laws apply to fashion brands in 2026?
The EU AI Act came into force on 2 August 2026, requiring brands to disclose AI-generated deepfakes clearly at first exposure. New York's Synthetic Performer Disclosure Law took effect on 9 June 2026, requiring conspicuous disclosure when ads feature AI-generated synthetic performers. California's SB 1050 requires disclosure from 1 January 2027.
Sources
- Glossy: In 2025, luxury fashion's AI marketing experiments hit a turning point
- Journal of Advertising Research: When AI Doesn't Sell Prada (June 2025)
- FashionUnited: How new AI disclosure laws are reshaping fashion advertising
- McKinsey: When AI meets desire (luxury experiences in the agentic age)
- Digital Market Reports: Valentino Faces Backlash After Posting AI-Generated Ads for DeVain Handbag
